Dog Collars

What’s the Best Dog Collar?

QUESTION: I’ve noticed lots of different kinds of collars on the market – choke collars, prong collars, leather collars, etc. How do I decide which one is appropriate for my dog?

Answered by: Julie Bjelland Lokhandwala


There are many different types of collars and choosing the right one can be confusing! To help sort it all out, I’ve listed a few types I feel make excellent choices. I’ll also mention a couple I don’t recommend–and explain why. First, the good options.

Recommended for use with ID tags, but not for walking if your dog pulls on leash:

Flat or rolled collars

Traditional leather, cotton or nylon buckle, or quick-release collars are good options for everyday collars you can hang your dog’s ID tags from. They do not tighten on the dog’s neck once they are fastened, and many people find that the rolled variety seems to cause less hair breakage. If your dog tends to pull on leash, however, you do NOT want to use this type of collar for walking.

Break-away collars

These are similar to the ones above, but if a break-away collar were to become caught on something, it would break open and release your dog.

Recommended for walking if your dog pulls:

Head collar

If you have a dog that tends to pull on leash, a head collar (like a gentle leader) can be a great option to help you walk your dog without pulling. It may look a bit like a muzzle, but it isn’t; the dog can bark, drink and eat with this collar. Note: A flexi-lead is not a good idea with this type of collar or with a neck collar, because when your dog gets to the end of the lead it’s easy to accidentally jerk the dog’s head.

Body harness

Another option is a body harness, which is worn around the dog’s body and hooks to the leash at the chest. Like the head collar, it does not put pressure on the neck.

NOT recommended:

Choke chain collars

Used for the type of training that uses jerk and release corrections when the dog does not obey a command. This type of collar tightens on the dog’s neck when the dog pulls. Studies have shown that choke type collars can cause injury to a dog’s neck, back, or trachea.

Prong collars

Also called pinch collars have spikes that dig into the dog’s neck and pinch them when pulled. They are usually used for large dogs that are heavy pullers.  Both the choke and prong collars can be painful for your dog and there are better, pain-free options.

Training your dog to walk without pulling is your best bet. It can take some time but the reward is worth it! Since training this takes some time, a head collar or body harness is a good short-term solution.

Julie Bjelland Lokhandwala’s interactive Dog Training Web site:, teaches you how to train your own dog as well as receive professional coaching, advice and tips through email consultations about your own dog!  Julie formerly trained Guide Dogs for the Blind and has been running her own successful obedience training/behavior modification business for several years. She is known for her talent in helping you communicate more effectively with your dog.   Julie’s positive methods of training are friendly, encouraging and motivating. She has a personal mission to help more dogs get adopted and stay adopted and donates a portion of her proceeds to the cause.  Julie shares her home with her own rescued German Shepherd, Fax.

This article was contributed by Julie Bjelland Lokhandwala the founder of webDogTrainer

webDogTrainer is a popular website that offers Consultations with Julie, the dog trainer, LIVE about any dog-training related questions you may have!  Also on the site you will find more in-depth information on how to train your dog to be the kind of dog you always wanted and how to fix problem behaviors should they occur.

Contact info: